vbgihs (vbgihs) wrote in who_got_in,
vbgihs
vbgihs
who_got_in

Philosophy Part 2

We're a talkative bunch.
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 3037 comments
Got an email from Christopher Morris. I am in the "middle" of the waitlist, but no indication of how large it is.
Grats. Judging the numbers posted earlier, you are part of a pretty small group.

Re: Waitlisted at Maryland

Anonymous

7 years ago

I thought they were going to notify by mail.
I flat-out distrust the gradcafe results board
a good number of the postings seem legitimate enough, but a lot are rather suspicious

Re: New School acceptance on gradcafe

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School acceptance on gradcafe

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School acceptance on gradcafe

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School acceptance on gradcafe

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School acceptance on gradcafe

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School acceptance on gradcafe

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School acceptance on gradcafe

Anonymous

7 years ago

Anonymous

March 14 2009, 03:09:10 UTC 7 years ago

Out of curiosity, has anyone been accepted at every school to which he/she applied?
hahahahahahahahahaha...

Anonymous

7 years ago

Anonymous

7 years ago

Anonymous

7 years ago

looks like a mass email just went out directing everyone to the website
Nothing here. No email. No update on website.

Troll?

Re: UCLA rejections

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: UCLA rejections

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: UCLA rejections

Anonymous

7 years ago

I emailed the department the other day, and got a short email back saying that they have made their initial offers and have a waitlist, and that I'm not on it. I would guess a lot of us are on this second-string waitlist (rejected).
Does anyone know if all waitllist notifications have gone out? It looks like someone just received notice a couple of days ago.

Re: U of Arizona

Anonymous

7 years ago

Has anyone heard from them yet?
I applied for the MPhilStud, but my application arrived late, so I am hoping that I am still considered.
Is anyone else pretty much suicidal b/c the knowledge that notifications are imminent is just too much to bear?
I gotta make it through Sunday, then Monday the mail always arrives late. At worst, I'll get my letter Tuesday.
I think I might die.
NSSR is pretty much my last chance at PhD, because I don't have a good feeling about Fordham and Duquesne.

bad news

Anonymous

March 14 2009, 18:33:44 UTC 7 years ago

They said they'd be SENT by Tuesday. Unless your letter has already been mailed and you live in New York there is a good chance you won't get the New School letter on Tuesday but later.

Re: bad news

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School Notifications

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School Notifications

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School Notifications

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: New School Notifications

Anonymous

7 years ago

Student P won't decline University A unless she gets in off of the waitlist for University B

Student Q won't decline university B unless she gets in off the waitlist for university A.

P and Q might each be in contact with the departments, and each student could be aware that there is one spot preventing an admission offer.

What happens? Do the DGS ask where else they're each considering so as to remediate these situations?

Is it that eventually P or Q givess in and accepts the 2nd choice spot, leading to the other student finding out that she's no longer on the waitlist and thus accepting her 2nd choice spot?

I wonder how often, if ever, this happens. Or if more complicated and yet symmetric admissions occur, for example:

P in at UofA, WL at UofB.
Q in at UofB, WL at UofC.
R in at UofC, WL at UofA.
(assume 1st choice of each is the WL place.)

Just going nuts over the waiting game and thinking.
ugh
this post reminds me of the damn GRE

(which seems like such a waste at this point)

Re: does this really ever happen?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: does this really ever happen?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Some people have received rejections from Rutgers. Are others still waiting to hear?
I'm waiting. I wonder if those rejections were people who contacted the department.

Re: Rutgers status?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Rutgers status?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Rutgers status?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Rutgers status?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Rutgers status?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Rutgers status?

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Rutgers status?

twasher

7 years ago

Re: Rutgers status?

Anonymous

7 years ago

I gather not many people applying to Minnesota are hanging out here.
I heard that on the prospective student weekend, other than the 6 offered, only 3 of the long 16 waitlist showed up.
Are any of you considering other schools at the moment? I heard 3 are definetely taking the offers!
I am far enough down the wait list that I did not think it worth while to fly out to see the program. That being said, if it comes through, I will likely accept the offer.
Does anyone have any info on University of Virginia? Acceptances or rejections? I have no online status updates or skinny envelopes, but I would imagine something has happened by now.

Re: UVa

Anonymous

March 15 2009, 03:15:52 UTC 7 years ago

Mitch Green posted a message on the original board that indicated that if you have yet to receive word from UVa, you are likely on the wait list. He also said that he invites any applicant who would like specifics on his/her application status to email him.

Re: UVa

omgphilosophy

7 years ago

Re: UVa

ttuphilosopher

7 years ago

Re: UVa

omgphilosophy

7 years ago

Re: UVa

ttuphilosopher

7 years ago

Re: UVa

Anonymous

7 years ago

I know there are a lot of these types of posts, but... I can't help it. Anyone?
I received the email from Marquette telling me to check my application status on their web page: denied.

I also received and email from Dr. Brogan at Villanova informing me that I am high on their waitlist and that he believes he will be able to get the funding together to accept me.

So, to recap:
SUNY Buffalo: accepted with no funding
Villanova: waitlisted with prospect of funding if accepted
Marquette: rejected
Notre Dame: rejection forthcoming
Toronto: oh why oh why do you torture us you tricksy Canadians?
You sound like a Franciscan University student, if I am not mistaken.

Re: Marquette and Villanova

Anonymous

7 years ago

I'm an international student who got rejected to all the schools to which he applied (still waiting for arizona and washU). I don't get why. I'm objectively a quite good student: one Master's in philosophy from the Sorbonne and one in cognitive science from what is supposed to be the best program in France (and one of the best in Europe), the researchers with whom I'm working are quite famous, and I'm on my way to getting published. I am also fluent in english, so no problem for teaching. I just don't see why I didn't even got waitlsted at Florida State....
Possible reasons:
- undergrad grades a bit lower than my grad grades
- poor GRE scores: V-540 Q-660 W-4.5
- writing sample not good enough (I've had some good feedback though...)
- national preference?? (a little skeptical about that one)


I suspect the GRE was the major cause of me being rejected while others with a nice background AND a high GRE score have been accepted. Any thoughts? I'm trying to determine what in my application would have to be improved if I decide to re-apply next year.

Did you apply to state and private schools? I ask because for state schools an international student with funding is a big burden and the bar IS higher. If you didn't get into top private schools, your GRE and grades may have played a role. But I think that the problem was your writing sample. Because you have a master in cognitive science and a masters from France (is your program more continental than analytic) I suspect that maybe your writing sample was not so much a philosophy paper, but a cog. sci/phil paper. And this could be risky for admissions at US schools.

Re: I just don't get it

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: I just don't get it

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: I just don't get it

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: I just don't get it

Anonymous

7 years ago

Does anyone know what the average GRE is at the top programs? Someone just said Rutgers is about 1500. How about NYU? Princeton?

I'm not sure where the poster about Rutgers got the 1500 figure, since it says on Rutgers' website, "we don't have precise data on [average GREs and GPAs of admitted students]. On average GRE scores tend to be very high, around 96% or above". As far as I am aware, most other top programs either do not track or do not publicly declare the average GREs. One exception is UT Austin, which states on its website that the median GRE score for admitted students in 2007 was 1470. (Michigan's website does not state averages, but states that "scores for the verbal and quantitative sections of the GRE range from 650 to 800; scores for the analytic section of the GRE range from 5.5 to 6.")

Re: Average GRE at top programs

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Average GRE at top programs

Anonymous

7 years ago

Consolation prize. Oh well...
Just curious: is this program worth it?
I know a person who did the program and has had success with PhD admissions this year. This person also seems to have benefited greatly as far as knowledge and philosophical ability are concerned.
If we haven't heard from a department by March 15, should we email to ask what the deal is? Who should we email in these cases? Should we call?
I see many UCLA rejections on grad cafe. Has anyone been accepted there yet?
Yes, there have been a few reported UCLA acceptances. Emails went out on the 10th.

Re: UCLA accepted?

Anonymous

7 years ago

I saw a couple of posts further up professing to come to despise the philosophy "game", and there's a rejection posting on TGC for Villanova says much the same thing. I was wondering if anyone else had an opinion about this. Anyone else out there who would rather see philosophy in public and in more places, like high schools, than guarantee themselves a tenure-track job in a university?

How could we get philosophy into the US public school system? Would it take a philosophy lobby?
I'm the professed hater on these boards

I'm beginning to feel that the constructing infrastructure of Academia is stifling to the free and critical spirit of philosophy. It's almost counter-productive.
Unfortunately, philosophy IS an academic enterprise. 'Serious work' occurs within the elite academy, and anyone who 'popularizes' philosophy is for that reason not taken seriously (e.g., Zizek, the "funny man")--even if the depth, rigor, and quality of their work remains of high caliber.

It's just so ugly.
I'm beginning to reconsider my priorities. I don't want to burn out. I want to remain REAL and passionate. If I have to hide my radical feminism in order to get ahead, I'm not sure I want to. I'd rather be true to myself than sell my soul for a chance to make it in the philosophy game.

I still want a PhD, because I LOVE school and want to write a dissertation, but I'm not sure if Professorship is conducive to my goals in life. Maybe my talents will be better used in some other fashion-- I could be a feminist icon!

I'm realizing that the past few years have been nothing but studying. I don't know if I want the rest of my life to be like that. Applied philosophy instead?

Any other thoughts?

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

master leiter would be proud.

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: On the hatred of academic philosophy

Anonymous

7 years ago

Nothing much is posted on gradcafe, one acceptance, one rejection between them.
search back through posts and you will see it looks like everyone who was admitted/waitlisted to harvard heard a week or two ago
So this was at Wisconsin, right? Anyone who was there able to elaborate? Or was this in the Education Policy department?
Isn't this supposed to be the legendary "final day" for graduate schools to alert their first round acceptances? Who is left?
I have yet to hear from several, (Miami, NYU, Notre Dame, U-Mass Amherst,) but others have been accepted at all of these places, so I'm not expecting anything fantastic (though a waitlist or two would be pretty great).

Or maybe this deadline thing was just made up by one of the anonymous posters here, and nothing exciting will happen today.
I am hoping that ASU contacts me today, but they probably won't until weeks from now.

Re: So this is it...

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: So this is it...

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: So this is it...

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: So this is it...

Anonymous

7 years ago

And if so, are you accepting the offer? (My apologies if this has been discussed already; I'm somewhat new here.)
I was accepted at WMU with funding, and have turned down the offer.

Maybe you already know, but this website has searchable postings of admission results:
http://thegradcafe.com/survey/index.php?q=philosophy+western+michigan&t=a&pp=25

(There's been some controversy this year regarding fake postings, but I don't expect anyone would be interested in posting fake WMU results.)
Finally got an email from NYU. Not that I really thought I was in at this point, but it sure took them a long ass time. They said they snail mailed notifications out a week and a half ago. I think they lied. I live a mile from NYU and I haven't gotten anything until today, which was an email. Fuck this shit.
Has anyone else not heard anything from NYU(not that I take having not heard as a good sign - I'm just wondering)?

Re: Finally got NYU rejection.

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Finally got NYU rejection.

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Finally got NYU rejection.

Anonymous

7 years ago

Re: Finally got NYU rejection.

Anonymous

7 years ago